Blog

First-party fraud is now a third of all fraud. The 2027 dispute problem

First-party (“friendly”) fraud has roughly doubled its share of cases in two years. Why ordinary customers now drive so many chargebacks, and the order-time evidence that protects you.

One of the most important numbers in fraud right now is not about hackers at all. By 2026 industry data put first-party fraud — where the legitimate account holder is the one disputing a charge they really made — at roughly a third of all fraud cases, up from around 15% just two years earlier. Call it friendly fraud if you like, though there is nothing friendly about it. It is now one of the largest and fastest-growing threats to a merchant's margin, and it is heading into 2027 with momentum.

Why it is exploding

  • Disputing is frictionless. A chargeback is a few taps in a banking app. "I don't recognise this" is faster than contacting the merchant, and often more profitable.
  • Economic pressure. When budgets tighten, "cardholder's remorse" rises — people dispute purchases they genuinely made but now regret.
  • It feels victimless. Many customers do not think of a wrongful dispute as fraud, which is exactly why it scales.
  • Subscriptions and digital goods are especially exposed: easy to use, then easy to claim were never wanted.

Why it is so hard to fight

First-party fraud is uniquely awkward because the "fraudster" is your real customer, logging in from their real account and their real device, using their real card. Every signal that catches an outsider says this person is legitimate — because, as an account holder, they are. You cannot block your way out of it at checkout without punishing good customers. The battle is won later, at the dispute, and it is won with evidence.

Build the evidence at order time

Winning a first-party dispute means proving the account holder placed the order and received the value. The time to capture that proof is when the order happens, not when the chargeback lands weeks later. Record, per order, the signals that reconstruct the transaction convincingly:

  • The network the order genuinely came from, and whether it matched the customer's usual origin — strong evidence the real account holder, not an impostor, placed it.
  • The issuing country of the card, from the BIN, tied to the account.
  • Delivery, access or usage confirmation showing the value was received.

A clean record that the account's own network and card placed and received the order is what turns a dispute in your favour.

Capture origin on every order

Fraudex gives you the network and issuing-country signals to log on every transaction, in one call, so the evidence is already in hand when a "friendly" dispute arrives. See the VPN detection API, the proxy detection API and the BIN lookup API.